Sie sind hier

Social Network

#Friendica vs #Hubzilla vs #Mastodon

I've been running a #Friendica node for several years now. Some months ago I also started to run a #Hubzilla hub as well. Some days ago I also installed #Mastodon on a virtual machine, because there was so much hype about Mastodon in the last days due to some changes Twitter made in regards of 3rd party clients.

All of those social networks do have their own focus:

Friendica: basically can connect to all other social networks, which is quite nice because there exists historically two different worlds: the Federation (Diaspora, Socialhome) and the Fediverse (GnuSocial, Mastodon, postActiv, Pleroma). Only Friendica and Hubzilla can federate with both: Federation and Fediverse.
Friendicas look&feel appears sometimes a little bit outdated and old, but it works very well and reliable.

Hubzilla: is the second player in the field of connecting both federations, but has a different focus. It is more of one-size-fits-all approach. If you need a microblogging site, a wiki, a cloud service, a website, etc. then Hubzilla is the way to go. The look&feel is a little bit more modern, but there are some quirks that appears a little odd to me. A unique feature for Hubzilla seems to be the concept of "nomadic accounts": you can move to a different hub and take all your data with you. Read more about that in the Hubzilla documentation.

Mastodon: this aims to be a replacement for Twitter as a microblogging service. It looks nice and shiny, has a bunch of nice clients for smartphones and has the largest userbase by far (which is not that important because of federation).
But the web GUI is rather limited and weird, as far as I can tell after just some days.

Technically spoken these are the main differences:
- Friendica: MySQL/MariaDB, PHP on the server, Clients: some Android clients, no iOS client
- Hubzilla: MySQL/MariaDB or PostgreSQL, PHP on the server, Clients: don't know, didn't care so far.
- Mastodon: PostgreSQL, Ruby on the server, Clients: many iOS and Android clients available

I'm not that big Ruby fan and if I remember correctly the Ruby stuff turned me away from Diaspora years ago and made me switch to Friendica, because back then it was a pain to maintain Diaspora. Mastodon addresses this by offering Docker container for the ease of installation and maintenance. But as I'm no Docker fan either, I followed the guide to install Mastodon without Docker, which works so far as well (for the last 3 days ).

So after all my Friendica node is still my favorit, because is just works and is reliable. Hubzilla has a different approach and offers a full set of webfeatures and nomadic accounts. The best I can say about Mastodon at this moment is: it runs on PostgreSQL and has nice clients on mobile devices.

Here are my instances:
- Friendica: https://nerdica.net/
- Hubzilla: https://silverhaze.eu/
- Mastodon: https://nerdculture.de/

PS: "A quick guide to The Free Network" by Sean Tilley on https://medium.com/we-distribute/a-quick-guide-to-the-free-network-c0693...

PPS: this is a cross post from my Friendica node.

Kategorie: 
 

#DeleteFacebook and alternative Social Networks

Some weeks ago a more or less large scandal popped up in the media: Cambridge Analytica misused data from Facebook. Many users of Facebook were unhappy about abusing their personal data and deleted their Facebook accounts - or at least tried some alternatives like Friendica, Hubzilla, Diaspora, Mastodon and others.

There has been a significant increase in user count since then and this gave a general boost for the networks.

Apropos networks... basically there are two large networks: The Federation (Diaspora, Socialhome) and The Fediverse (GNU Social, Mastodon, postActiv, Pleroma). Within the two networks all solution can exchange information like posts, comments, user information and such, or in other words: they federate with each other. So, when you use Mastodon your posts won't be available to Diaspora users and vice versa as they use different protocols for federation.

And here Friendica and Hubzilla do have their advantage: both are able to federate with both networks. Sean Tilley has some more information in his article "A quick guide to The Free Network" on medium.com.

Another great resource you can use to find more about alternatives to Facebook is the great new Fediverse Wiki.

From my point of view I would recommend either Friendica or Hubzilla, depending on what you want:

  • Friendica is in my opinion the best solution to have best of both worlds, i.e. Fediverse und Federation. It has active developers and a good and helping community. It concentrates on the social network topic.
  • Hubzilla is a more complete approach: you can add addons to have a cloud space, a wiki or create web pages.

Both offers you to create multiple profiles with one account (Friendica: profiles, Hubzilla: channels) and of course you have a fine-grained control about your content. There is also a fresh Youtube channel describing some Friendica features. Although it is in German, others might get some helpful hints as well from those videos.

Which alternative will be the best for you is up to you to decide. All alternatives have their pros and cons. If you don't already have a website, cloud space or such, Hubzilla might be the best choice for you. If you don't need such additional functions, you might be best suited with Friendica. If you like to install docker images, Mastodon will make you happy.

In the end, it's all about choice! You will have better control about your own data in all cases. You can run your own instance, make it private only, or you can join one of the available servers and try out what best suites you. For Friendica you can find some public servers on https://dir.friendica.social.

I'm running a Friendica node on https://nerdica.net/ as well as a Hubzilla hub on https://silverhaze.eu/ - feel invited to try both and register on either one to have a look onto some alternatives for Facebook.

After all: Decentralize and spread the workd! Use the alternatives you have and don't sell you privacy to the big players like Facebook and Google if you don't need to. :-)

PS: If you are already on one of those alternative networks, please feel free to connect me on my Friendica node or Hubzilla hub!

Kategorie: 
 

Seiten

Theme by Danetsoft and Danang Probo Sayekti inspired by Maksimer